Sunday, September 2, 2012
Prefering Order to Justice
"In the decade since 9/11, much has been written about the “War on Terror” and the lack of justice for people detained at Guantanamo or subjected to rendition and torture in CIA black sites. A central focus of the critique is the unreviewability of Executive branch action toward those detained and tried in military commissions. In those critiques, the federal courts are regularly celebrated for their due process and other rights protections. Yet in the past ten years, there has been little scrutiny of the hundreds of terrorism cases tried in the Article III courts and the state of the rights of people accused of terrrorism-related offenses in the federal system. The deference to assertions of national security that degraded protections for detainees at Guantanamo has similarly degraded the protections for Muslims facing terrorism charges in the federal courts. This [American University Law Review] Essay provides a close examination of one of those cases—that of Syed Fahad Hashmi—and reveals rights abridgement throughout the legal process (intrusive surveillance, vague material support charges, the use of prolonged pre-trial solitary confinement, classified evidence, the use of political activities to demonstrate mindset and intent). The federal courts have permitted such rights abridgements, largely abdicating their role as a check on Executive power and imperiling the rights of those being tried in the Article III courts." See http://www.aulawreview.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=1919%3Aprefering-order-to-justice&catid=266%3Avolume-61-issue-5&Itemid=144
Saturday, April 28, 2012
39 Ways to Limit Free Speech
Google “39 Ways to Serve and Participate in Jihad” and you’ll get over 590,000 hits. You’ll find full-text English language translations of this Arabic document on the Internet Archive, an Internet library; on 4Shared Desktop, a file-sharing site; and on numerous Islamic sites. You will find it cited and discussed in a US Senate Committee staff report and Congressional testimony. Feel free to read it. Just don’t try to make your own translation from the original, which was written in Arabic in Saudi Arabia in 2003. Because if you look a little further on Google you will find multiple news accounts reporting that on April 12, a 29-year old citizen from Sudbury, Massachusetts named Tarek Mehanna was sentenced to seventeen and a half years in prison for translating “39 Ways” and helping to distribute it online. Read More: http://www.nybooks.com/blogs/nyrblog/2012/apr/19/39-ways-limit-free-speech/
New York Review of Books article by David Cole, April 19, 2012
Saturday, March 10, 2012
ACLU Alert: Urge Congress to fix National Defense Authorization Act
In this action alert, the ACLU urges citizens to take action to fix the National Defense Authorization Act
Will Congress Finally Start to Clean Up the Mess It Made With the NDAA?
Posted by Chris Anders, Washington Legislative Office at 12:16pm
Excerpt:
On Wednesday at 10:00 a.m. EST, the Senate Judiciary Committee will hold the first hearing ever on the indefinite military detention provisions in the 2012 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), which Congress passed in December. This hearing will be Congress' first opportunity to own up to its mistakes and start to fix them. But the only way the NDAA will be fixed is if senators and House members hear from you and your family and friends that indefinite military detention authority is wrong, dangerous, and needs to be repealed.
As we've said before, the NDAA is dangerous because it authorizes this president and all future presidents to order the military to lock away civilians picked up far from any battlefield, in indefinite detention without charge or trial based on suspicion alone. It could permit any president to send the American military to imprison people anywhere in the world, even where there is no armed conflict and no threat to Americans.
Unbelievably, some members of Congress even rejected amendments clarifying that the NDAA military detention provisions do not apply inside the U.S.
Take action to notify your members of Congress.
Will Congress Finally Start to Clean Up the Mess It Made With the NDAA?
Posted by Chris Anders, Washington Legislative Office at 12:16pm
Excerpt:
On Wednesday at 10:00 a.m. EST, the Senate Judiciary Committee will hold the first hearing ever on the indefinite military detention provisions in the 2012 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), which Congress passed in December. This hearing will be Congress' first opportunity to own up to its mistakes and start to fix them. But the only way the NDAA will be fixed is if senators and House members hear from you and your family and friends that indefinite military detention authority is wrong, dangerous, and needs to be repealed.
As we've said before, the NDAA is dangerous because it authorizes this president and all future presidents to order the military to lock away civilians picked up far from any battlefield, in indefinite detention without charge or trial based on suspicion alone. It could permit any president to send the American military to imprison people anywhere in the world, even where there is no armed conflict and no threat to Americans.
Unbelievably, some members of Congress even rejected amendments clarifying that the NDAA military detention provisions do not apply inside the U.S.
Take action to notify your members of Congress.
Sunday, March 4, 2012
For Abu-Ali Family, Only One Legal Avenue Left for Son’s Freedom
I became aware of this case through activists with whom I worked on Fahad Hashmi case. To donate to the Ahmed Abu Ali Defense Fund and for more information, see http://freeahmed.com/.
For Abu-Ali Family, Only One Legal Avenue Left for Son’s Freedom
Written by Contributing Writers
Thursday, February 23, 2012
(Reprinted from The Muslim Link)
We are all familiar with this tale: a young man gets arrested by surprise, held for years without charges, shackled for days at a time, whipped past the point of burning, interrogated through the nights, threatened with death, forced into confession, and ultimately incarcerated for life. Perhaps we have read George Orwell’s 1984, heard about Adolf Hitler’s Germany, or seen the horrors of Bashar Al-Assad’s current Syria on our television screens. But in fact, this nightmare is neither fiction nor history nor foreign. It is right here, right now, in our backyards.
It is the life story of an American: Ahmed Abu-Ali. Born in Texas, Ahmed completed high school in Northern Virginia where he graduated as valedictorian and spent his free time working with disabled adults, teaching children how to read, and building bridges in interfaith activities. He served as a summer counselor and youth group leader at Dar Al Hijrah, and donated blood regularly to the American Red Cross. He is a Muslim American, a brother, a son, and most of all your Muslim brother.
Ahmed dreamed of becoming a teacher full-time one day. Just before graduating college, when Ahmed was set to fulfill his lifelong dream in his Northern Virginia hometown, his life took an unexpected turn.
On June 8, 2003, at the age of 22, Ahmed was suddenly arrested while studying Islamic Studies in Saudi Arabia, amidst a final exam. He was detained and held in jail for 20 months without charges or access to attorney. After his family sued the U.S government, he was unexpectedly sent back to the U.S., where he was convicted for terrorism-related conspiracy charges on the basis of a false confession that was elicited by torture. Many details in Ahmed’s case illustrate the extent to which it was fabricated. For instance, Ahmed is the first person in all of U.S. history who was arrested based entirely on secret evidence. Also, his case set a precedent on evidence obtained by a foreign government by torture. Furthermore, the judge at his trial refused to allow evidence of possible torture to be presented.
Today, at age 30, Ahmed spends 23 hours a day everyday in solitary confinement at ADX Supermax Prison in Florence, Colorado. If he would like to take his one-hour of “recreation,” into a 5x5 metal cage where he gets a small view of the sky, he must get strip-searched. His cell measures 8×12 feet, located 20 meters beneath the ground. The last time Ahmed got a hug, he was also 22. Special Administrative Measures prohibit Ahmed from any outside contact, except sparse, limited, and monitored correspondences with his immediate family and attorney. When his family visits, they communicate with him via telephone and take turns watching him through the glass, with his feet still shackled.
For the past eight years and eight months, Ahmed has been fighting for justice, and repeatedly denied his basic rights as an American citizen—the right for a Miranda statement, the right to an attorney, the right to a speedy trial, the right to know your accuser, the right to know the evidence against you, , and the protection from cruel and unusual punishments. In our U.S. courts, under the banner of liberty and justice for all, Ahmed has been stripped of his 4th, 5th and 6th amendment rights.
Now it is our turn to demand justice. Ahmed’s family has exhausted their legal options. The last leg of this legal battle is the writ of habeas corpus, a procedure for release from unlawful detention. To ensure success, Ahmed needs your support. Please Follow Ahmed on Twitter @BringAhmedHome, Like Ahmed on the Facebook page “Free Ahmed,” and join us at the upcoming Freedom Dinner on March 3rd at Dewan-E-Khaas in Ahmed’s hometown, Northern Virginia. For students who donate, an anonymous donor will not only match but double their donations up to 1k. If you have an upcoming special occasion, consider purchasing a Freedom Cake or other desserts. For other ways to help, please visit http://freeahmed.com/take-action/. If we don’t speak up for Ahmed, who will? Let us not turn our back on a brother in need. Help free Ahmed by visiting www.freeahmed.com
As Ahmed waits, silenced in his cell, it is up to us to spread the word. We are the voice of the voiceless. We are not afraid to broadcast the truth. We are not afraid to stand up for the innocent. We will free Ahmed, and set a precedent that never again will we allow another Ahmed to be unjustly persecuted on our soil.
For Abu-Ali Family, Only One Legal Avenue Left for Son’s Freedom
Written by Contributing Writers
Thursday, February 23, 2012
(Reprinted from The Muslim Link)
We are all familiar with this tale: a young man gets arrested by surprise, held for years without charges, shackled for days at a time, whipped past the point of burning, interrogated through the nights, threatened with death, forced into confession, and ultimately incarcerated for life. Perhaps we have read George Orwell’s 1984, heard about Adolf Hitler’s Germany, or seen the horrors of Bashar Al-Assad’s current Syria on our television screens. But in fact, this nightmare is neither fiction nor history nor foreign. It is right here, right now, in our backyards.
It is the life story of an American: Ahmed Abu-Ali. Born in Texas, Ahmed completed high school in Northern Virginia where he graduated as valedictorian and spent his free time working with disabled adults, teaching children how to read, and building bridges in interfaith activities. He served as a summer counselor and youth group leader at Dar Al Hijrah, and donated blood regularly to the American Red Cross. He is a Muslim American, a brother, a son, and most of all your Muslim brother.
Ahmed dreamed of becoming a teacher full-time one day. Just before graduating college, when Ahmed was set to fulfill his lifelong dream in his Northern Virginia hometown, his life took an unexpected turn.
On June 8, 2003, at the age of 22, Ahmed was suddenly arrested while studying Islamic Studies in Saudi Arabia, amidst a final exam. He was detained and held in jail for 20 months without charges or access to attorney. After his family sued the U.S government, he was unexpectedly sent back to the U.S., where he was convicted for terrorism-related conspiracy charges on the basis of a false confession that was elicited by torture. Many details in Ahmed’s case illustrate the extent to which it was fabricated. For instance, Ahmed is the first person in all of U.S. history who was arrested based entirely on secret evidence. Also, his case set a precedent on evidence obtained by a foreign government by torture. Furthermore, the judge at his trial refused to allow evidence of possible torture to be presented.
Today, at age 30, Ahmed spends 23 hours a day everyday in solitary confinement at ADX Supermax Prison in Florence, Colorado. If he would like to take his one-hour of “recreation,” into a 5x5 metal cage where he gets a small view of the sky, he must get strip-searched. His cell measures 8×12 feet, located 20 meters beneath the ground. The last time Ahmed got a hug, he was also 22. Special Administrative Measures prohibit Ahmed from any outside contact, except sparse, limited, and monitored correspondences with his immediate family and attorney. When his family visits, they communicate with him via telephone and take turns watching him through the glass, with his feet still shackled.
For the past eight years and eight months, Ahmed has been fighting for justice, and repeatedly denied his basic rights as an American citizen—the right for a Miranda statement, the right to an attorney, the right to a speedy trial, the right to know your accuser, the right to know the evidence against you, , and the protection from cruel and unusual punishments. In our U.S. courts, under the banner of liberty and justice for all, Ahmed has been stripped of his 4th, 5th and 6th amendment rights.
Now it is our turn to demand justice. Ahmed’s family has exhausted their legal options. The last leg of this legal battle is the writ of habeas corpus, a procedure for release from unlawful detention. To ensure success, Ahmed needs your support. Please Follow Ahmed on Twitter @BringAhmedHome, Like Ahmed on the Facebook page “Free Ahmed,” and join us at the upcoming Freedom Dinner on March 3rd at Dewan-E-Khaas in Ahmed’s hometown, Northern Virginia. For students who donate, an anonymous donor will not only match but double their donations up to 1k. If you have an upcoming special occasion, consider purchasing a Freedom Cake or other desserts. For other ways to help, please visit http://freeahmed.com/take-action/. If we don’t speak up for Ahmed, who will? Let us not turn our back on a brother in need. Help free Ahmed by visiting www.freeahmed.com
As Ahmed waits, silenced in his cell, it is up to us to spread the word. We are the voice of the voiceless. We are not afraid to broadcast the truth. We are not afraid to stand up for the innocent. We will free Ahmed, and set a precedent that never again will we allow another Ahmed to be unjustly persecuted on our soil.
Saturday, January 7, 2012
Selecting the Next City Council Speaker
Next to the mayoral election, the most important election in NYC is one in which most voters will be locked out of the process: The selection of City Council Speaker is decided by Council members, not the public, and usually only after deals with the leaders of each borough's Democratic Party.
This is not a democratic process, and it shouldn't be allowed to play out when the next Speaker is selected after next year's municipal elections.
The Speaker of the City Council is the second-most powerful public official in New York City,and is the single individual with the institutional authority to stand up to the mayor, whoever that happens to be. Voters should insist that we have input into the selection of the next Speaker.
According to a recent story in The New York Observer, the early race for Speaker is shaping up as a battle between Council Members Mellissa Mark Viverto and Inez Dickens, who represent neighboring districts in Harlem. One unidentified council member described the differences between the two contenders this way: "It's rabble-rouser, change-the-whole-place left-wing Melissa, and old-school, old world, status quo Inez."
I urge voters and political activists to pose this question to City Council candidates: If you are elected, who will you support to become the next Speaker of the City Council? This decision is too important to be left to five Democratic Party leaders, or even to the 51 members of the City Council. The rest of us have a right to be heard on this momentous decision.
This is not a democratic process, and it shouldn't be allowed to play out when the next Speaker is selected after next year's municipal elections.
The Speaker of the City Council is the second-most powerful public official in New York City,and is the single individual with the institutional authority to stand up to the mayor, whoever that happens to be. Voters should insist that we have input into the selection of the next Speaker.
According to a recent story in The New York Observer, the early race for Speaker is shaping up as a battle between Council Members Mellissa Mark Viverto and Inez Dickens, who represent neighboring districts in Harlem. One unidentified council member described the differences between the two contenders this way: "It's rabble-rouser, change-the-whole-place left-wing Melissa, and old-school, old world, status quo Inez."
I urge voters and political activists to pose this question to City Council candidates: If you are elected, who will you support to become the next Speaker of the City Council? This decision is too important to be left to five Democratic Party leaders, or even to the 51 members of the City Council. The rest of us have a right to be heard on this momentous decision.
Mayor Dinkins' Silence on Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly
I recently attended a judicial induction during which two speakers briefly noted the discriminary practices of the New York City Police Department.
Unfortunately, one speaker, former Mayor David N. Dinkins, had nothing to say about the NYPD or about the commissioner he empowered, Raymond W. Kelly. As the mayor who first appointed Kelly to head the NYPD, Dinkins is in a unique position to call Kelly to task for his department's systemic violations of civil liberties in New York City under Mayor Michael Bloomberg.
Dinkins' continuing public silence about Commissioner Kelly's transgressions is troubling, to say the least.
Unfortunately, one speaker, former Mayor David N. Dinkins, had nothing to say about the NYPD or about the commissioner he empowered, Raymond W. Kelly. As the mayor who first appointed Kelly to head the NYPD, Dinkins is in a unique position to call Kelly to task for his department's systemic violations of civil liberties in New York City under Mayor Michael Bloomberg.
Dinkins' continuing public silence about Commissioner Kelly's transgressions is troubling, to say the least.
Wednesday, December 7, 2011
Racist Facebook Rants by NYPD Officers
"I say have the parade one more year and when they gather drop a bomb and wipe them all out." - NYC Police Officer Dan Rodney, who confirmed to The New York Times that he is a police officer and uses Facebook but denied posting the comment on Facebook under his name. His explanation: "That wasn't me. I leave my phone around sometimes. Other than that I have no comment."
"'Let them kill each... other,' wrote one of the Facebook members who posted comments under a name that matched that of a police officer."
In a front-page story on 12/6/11, The New York Times reported on the racist rants in September of a Facebook group entitled "No More West Indian Day Detail." The Times did a comparison of the names "of some of the more than 150 people who posted comments on the page with city employee listings and found that more than 60 percent matched the names of police officers..." This Facebook group, which had 1,200 members, was exposed by defense attorneys who now check to see if arresting officers are on Facebook, has since vanished.
The Times notes that some of the posted comments "appeared to have broken Police Department rules barring officers from 'discourteous or disrepectful remarks' about race or ethnicity." The chief spokesperson for the NYPD did not deny that the names posted in the Facebook group were police officers and said he would refer the issue to Internal Affairs.
Police may insist that the Facebook rants on "No More West Indian Day Detail" are not representative of the thinking of most officers. But the racist public posts by this group are a shocking revelation, with names attached, of the attitudes of too many.
Scott
"'Let them kill each... other,' wrote one of the Facebook members who posted comments under a name that matched that of a police officer."
In a front-page story on 12/6/11, The New York Times reported on the racist rants in September of a Facebook group entitled "No More West Indian Day Detail." The Times did a comparison of the names "of some of the more than 150 people who posted comments on the page with city employee listings and found that more than 60 percent matched the names of police officers..." This Facebook group, which had 1,200 members, was exposed by defense attorneys who now check to see if arresting officers are on Facebook, has since vanished.
The Times notes that some of the posted comments "appeared to have broken Police Department rules barring officers from 'discourteous or disrepectful remarks' about race or ethnicity." The chief spokesperson for the NYPD did not deny that the names posted in the Facebook group were police officers and said he would refer the issue to Internal Affairs.
Police may insist that the Facebook rants on "No More West Indian Day Detail" are not representative of the thinking of most officers. But the racist public posts by this group are a shocking revelation, with names attached, of the attitudes of too many.
Scott
Sunday, August 14, 2011
17 Years Ago in the Bronx
Delgado v. City of New York, 14684/95
Appellate Division, First Department
Decided: July 28, 2011
The facts of this case are shocking.
Seventeen years ago, twelve NYC Housing Authority police officers terrorized the sleeping Delgado family in the Bronx, when officers crashed through the family's apartment door in the middle of the night, held guns to the head of the two oldest boys, slashed furniture, destroyed property, and threatened to place the youngest children in foster care if they found what they were looking for - drugs or weapons.
After searching for about three hours, the police found nothing and left.
On July 28, 2011, a New York appellate court agreed with a lower court's determination that the police lacked probable cause to search the family's apartment in the first place, because officers made no effort to corroborate an informant's information or to verify the reliability of the informant, who had been arrested for possession of crack cocaine.
The appellate court also noted that the police search did not constitute an emergency situation "given that six days elapsed between issuance and execution" of the search warrant.
The Appellate Division, First Department, dismissed the family's civil rights claim against the Housing Authority but allowed a lawsuit to proceed against the police captain who had approved the application for the warrant as well as the officer who had arrested the informant but failed to corroborate the informant's information.
It remains to be seen whether the Delgado family will ever receive any form of justice for the trauma which they collectively experienced seventeen years ago at the hands of the Housing Authority police.
Scott
Appellate Division, First Department
Decided: July 28, 2011
The facts of this case are shocking.
Seventeen years ago, twelve NYC Housing Authority police officers terrorized the sleeping Delgado family in the Bronx, when officers crashed through the family's apartment door in the middle of the night, held guns to the head of the two oldest boys, slashed furniture, destroyed property, and threatened to place the youngest children in foster care if they found what they were looking for - drugs or weapons.
After searching for about three hours, the police found nothing and left.
On July 28, 2011, a New York appellate court agreed with a lower court's determination that the police lacked probable cause to search the family's apartment in the first place, because officers made no effort to corroborate an informant's information or to verify the reliability of the informant, who had been arrested for possession of crack cocaine.
The appellate court also noted that the police search did not constitute an emergency situation "given that six days elapsed between issuance and execution" of the search warrant.
The Appellate Division, First Department, dismissed the family's civil rights claim against the Housing Authority but allowed a lawsuit to proceed against the police captain who had approved the application for the warrant as well as the officer who had arrested the informant but failed to corroborate the informant's information.
It remains to be seen whether the Delgado family will ever receive any form of justice for the trauma which they collectively experienced seventeen years ago at the hands of the Housing Authority police.
Scott
Labels:
Drugs,
Informants,
NYC Housing Authority,
NYC police
Sunday, May 29, 2011
My Tiny Protest
About two months ago, I attended an event at which the New York City Council presented Police Commissioner Raymond W. Kelly with the Thomas Manton Irish Man of the Year Award.
I stood near the front of the room and held up Leonard Levitt's book, "Power and Corruption in the Country's Greatest Police Force: NYPD Confidential." The Police Commissioner noticed, as did Council Speaker Christine Quinn and others in the room.
Eventually, someone, presumably an employee of the City Council, directed me to remove the book on the basis that I was being rude and disrespectful.
While I did lower the book, I nonetheless kept displaying it.
Compared to the protests taking place around the world in which people are risking their lives to stand up to dictators, my protest against the NYPD Commissioner was pretty tame. I didn't say anything. I didn't bring anyone with me or verbally disrupt the proceeding. All I did was hold up a book so others could see it, and in so doing, silently communicate my displeasure with the Council's guest of honor.
In a free country, citizens are supposed to have the right to criticize their government officials. This is a fundamental right which is enshrined in our First Amendment.
The New York City Council should respect freedom of speech and the right of citizens to criticize government officials.
I stood near the front of the room and held up Leonard Levitt's book, "Power and Corruption in the Country's Greatest Police Force: NYPD Confidential." The Police Commissioner noticed, as did Council Speaker Christine Quinn and others in the room.
Eventually, someone, presumably an employee of the City Council, directed me to remove the book on the basis that I was being rude and disrespectful.
While I did lower the book, I nonetheless kept displaying it.
Compared to the protests taking place around the world in which people are risking their lives to stand up to dictators, my protest against the NYPD Commissioner was pretty tame. I didn't say anything. I didn't bring anyone with me or verbally disrupt the proceeding. All I did was hold up a book so others could see it, and in so doing, silently communicate my displeasure with the Council's guest of honor.
In a free country, citizens are supposed to have the right to criticize their government officials. This is a fundamental right which is enshrined in our First Amendment.
The New York City Council should respect freedom of speech and the right of citizens to criticize government officials.
Thursday, May 19, 2011
Sparing a Political Boss
I'm not in the habit of agreeing with editorials in The New York Post. But The Post was right today to condemn the light sentence which was given to Raymond Harding, former chairman of the defunct Liberal Party, for fraud involving the state's pension fund.
Harding received no jail sentence or fine -- and was permitted to keep $800,000 which he pocketed in fees for serving as a sham intermediary between the pension fund and investment firms.
This was an inappropriate sentence for the political boss whose machinations were crucial to the election of Mayor Rudolph Giuliani. Harding tricked voters into voting for a political party which was neither liberal nor a real party, but instead was a patronage operation for his sons and friends.
It will be interesting to see if our senior elected officials and political prognosticators have anything to say about this sentence. I'm not holding my breath.
Harding received no jail sentence or fine -- and was permitted to keep $800,000 which he pocketed in fees for serving as a sham intermediary between the pension fund and investment firms.
This was an inappropriate sentence for the political boss whose machinations were crucial to the election of Mayor Rudolph Giuliani. Harding tricked voters into voting for a political party which was neither liberal nor a real party, but instead was a patronage operation for his sons and friends.
It will be interesting to see if our senior elected officials and political prognosticators have anything to say about this sentence. I'm not holding my breath.
Sunday, March 13, 2011
Shared Sacrifice
Politicians keep demanding "shared sacrifice" from public sector employees, although in reality the pain of layoffs and wage and benefit reductions is seldom shared.
Last week, I attended an event featuring Howard Wolfson, a NYC deputy mayor who in the private sector functioned as an attack dog for political candidates who preferred not to attack opponents directly (campaign examples: Bloomberg v Thompson and Clinton v Tasini).
When I asked Wolfson what sacrifices he was making, he repeated the Bloomberg line that wealthy people would leave NYC if taxes were increased on them.
Only after I repeated my question about Wolfson's own sacrifices did he respond directly by claiming that he made more money when he worked in the private sector. While undoubtedly this is true, it also is likely that our billionaire mayor will reward Wolfson for his relatively brief service in city government.
So again I pose the question, which should be asked of all politicians who oppose targeted tax increases but advocate solving budget problems through benefit reductions for employees and the public: Where is the shared sacrifice?
Wolfson other deputy mayors and commissioners should take substantial salary cuts before asking the rest of us for "shared sacrifice."
Scott
Last week, I attended an event featuring Howard Wolfson, a NYC deputy mayor who in the private sector functioned as an attack dog for political candidates who preferred not to attack opponents directly (campaign examples: Bloomberg v Thompson and Clinton v Tasini).
When I asked Wolfson what sacrifices he was making, he repeated the Bloomberg line that wealthy people would leave NYC if taxes were increased on them.
Only after I repeated my question about Wolfson's own sacrifices did he respond directly by claiming that he made more money when he worked in the private sector. While undoubtedly this is true, it also is likely that our billionaire mayor will reward Wolfson for his relatively brief service in city government.
So again I pose the question, which should be asked of all politicians who oppose targeted tax increases but advocate solving budget problems through benefit reductions for employees and the public: Where is the shared sacrifice?
Wolfson other deputy mayors and commissioners should take substantial salary cuts before asking the rest of us for "shared sacrifice."
Scott
Labels:
Howard Wolfson,
Michael Bloomberg,
Shared Sacrifice
Sunday, December 5, 2010
NYPD Internal Affairs
The Village Voice cover story about corruption and incompetence within the NYPD Internal Affairs Bureau ("Dirty Little Secrets in NYPD's Internal Affairs Bureau," December 1 - December 7, 2010) is outrageous on its face. The Voice story details a pattern in which Internal Affairs breaches confidentiality rules, drags out and buries investigations, provides little transparency and is arbitrary and capricious in its decisions.
Here is the link to the Voice story: http://www.villagevoice.com/2010-12-01/news/internal-injustice-in-nypd-s-internal-affairs-bureau/
As shocking as this story is, I'm equally disturbed by the silence of most elected officials in NYC to say anything publicly about this issue, or about the five cover stories in The Voice which exposed systemic abuse and civil liberties violations by the NYPD. In response to my questions, many elected officials tell me that they don't read The Voice and don't follow this issue closely.
Public officials have a civic responsibility to educate themselves about police misconduct - and to hold Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly accountable for civil liberties violations by his department.
Scott
Here is the link to the Voice story: http://www.villagevoice.com/2010-12-01/news/internal-injustice-in-nypd-s-internal-affairs-bureau/
As shocking as this story is, I'm equally disturbed by the silence of most elected officials in NYC to say anything publicly about this issue, or about the five cover stories in The Voice which exposed systemic abuse and civil liberties violations by the NYPD. In response to my questions, many elected officials tell me that they don't read The Voice and don't follow this issue closely.
Public officials have a civic responsibility to educate themselves about police misconduct - and to hold Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly accountable for civil liberties violations by his department.
Scott
Sunday, November 21, 2010
Congressman Rangel
The New York County Democratic Committee emailed party members to attend a Community Press Conference in support of Congressman Charles B. Rangel. County Leader Keith L.T. Wright wrote: “We want to let everyone know that we love our Congressman, that we have his back and that we want the Democrats to vote no to censure.”
The County Committee added: "Earlier this week, the House Ethics Committee found Rangel guilty of sloppy and careless mistakes, but not corruption, in the handling of his personal finances and support of a public service program at City College for minority students. The full House is expected to vote after the Thanksgiving break whether he should be censured for his errors."
I applaud Congressman Rangel's service to our country and his progressive leadership in the House of Representatives. But I must distinguish his positive contributions from his recent Ethics Committee conviction. At the very last minute, just as the hearing was to begin, Rangel chose to walk out (effectively waiving a defense), claiming that he couldn't afford legal representation - even though he was advised to set up a legal defense fund way back in 2008.
Charles Rangel's behavior is symbolic of the personal entitlement which typifies too many politicians once they forget that public service is one of the highest callings there is. Failure to pay income taxes on rental income and accepting four rent-stabilized apartments are not mere "sloppy and careless mistakes," as characterized by New York County Democrats. Rangel's conviction is a serious transgression which deserves punishment, regardless of the congressman's record and accomplishments in the House of Representatives.
Attending the "Community Press Conference" would send a message that ethics violations don't matter. I want no part of that message, so I didn't go.
Scott
The County Committee added: "Earlier this week, the House Ethics Committee found Rangel guilty of sloppy and careless mistakes, but not corruption, in the handling of his personal finances and support of a public service program at City College for minority students. The full House is expected to vote after the Thanksgiving break whether he should be censured for his errors."
I applaud Congressman Rangel's service to our country and his progressive leadership in the House of Representatives. But I must distinguish his positive contributions from his recent Ethics Committee conviction. At the very last minute, just as the hearing was to begin, Rangel chose to walk out (effectively waiving a defense), claiming that he couldn't afford legal representation - even though he was advised to set up a legal defense fund way back in 2008.
Charles Rangel's behavior is symbolic of the personal entitlement which typifies too many politicians once they forget that public service is one of the highest callings there is. Failure to pay income taxes on rental income and accepting four rent-stabilized apartments are not mere "sloppy and careless mistakes," as characterized by New York County Democrats. Rangel's conviction is a serious transgression which deserves punishment, regardless of the congressman's record and accomplishments in the House of Representatives.
Attending the "Community Press Conference" would send a message that ethics violations don't matter. I want no part of that message, so I didn't go.
Scott
Saturday, October 30, 2010
NYC Charter Questions
NYC voters should vote YES on the Charter Revision Commission's two charter questions, even if they are somewhat flawed.
Question 1 undoes the cynical term limits vote of the NYC Council which by legislative fiat wiped away two voter referenda on term limits.
Reasonable arguments can be made that a term limit of three terms is preferable to two; and that legislators should be subjected to longer term limits than executives, in order to strengthen the city council against all-powerful mayors.
Nonetheless, it is a conflict of interest for elected officials to decide the length of their own terms in office. Question 1 would restore the term limits law to what it was before the mayor and city council speaker put self-interest above the fundamental right of voters to decide this issue.
Question 2 is a muddled collection of unrelated items. On balance, though, the proposal is an improvement over the status quo.
Among other things, this proposal would reduce the number of petition signatures required for political candidates to appear on ballots, thereby weakening the Incumbent Protection Plan which is built into all elections.
In addition, Question 2 would amend the Charter to require individuals and entities to disclose expenditures designed to influence elections and referenda. Voters have the right to know about attempts to influence elections -- including secret expenditures aimed at buying party ballot lines.
I urge YES votes on both NYC charter questions.
Scott
Question 1 undoes the cynical term limits vote of the NYC Council which by legislative fiat wiped away two voter referenda on term limits.
Reasonable arguments can be made that a term limit of three terms is preferable to two; and that legislators should be subjected to longer term limits than executives, in order to strengthen the city council against all-powerful mayors.
Nonetheless, it is a conflict of interest for elected officials to decide the length of their own terms in office. Question 1 would restore the term limits law to what it was before the mayor and city council speaker put self-interest above the fundamental right of voters to decide this issue.
Question 2 is a muddled collection of unrelated items. On balance, though, the proposal is an improvement over the status quo.
Among other things, this proposal would reduce the number of petition signatures required for political candidates to appear on ballots, thereby weakening the Incumbent Protection Plan which is built into all elections.
In addition, Question 2 would amend the Charter to require individuals and entities to disclose expenditures designed to influence elections and referenda. Voters have the right to know about attempts to influence elections -- including secret expenditures aimed at buying party ballot lines.
I urge YES votes on both NYC charter questions.
Scott
Sunday, September 19, 2010
Jon Stewart's "Million Moderate March"
Jon Stewart has announced plans to organize a "Rally to Restore Sanity" in Washington, DC on October 30 - a rally which he also has called a "Million Moderate March."
Here is my response to the Daily Show's Facebook's posting:
- Scott
I like the Daily Show, but I must take issue with the whole idea of a Million Moderate March.
President Obama's problems stem from his efforts to be everything to everyone - instead of appealing to the progressives who once were his base.
Jon Stewart is fundamentally wrong when he compares, and equates, attacks from the right with those from the left - and cites as an example of unjustified attacks from the left those who accused President Bush of being a war criminal.
The Center for Constitutional Rights outlined a strong legal case for impeachment:
http://ccrjustice.org/files/impeach_06.03.06_AlterNet.pdf
The Bush administration was not held accountable for its assault on civil liberties through its use of extraordinary rendition, torture and the establishment of secret prisons beyond the reach of American law or international treaties.
Congress and the Obama administration made calculated political decisions not to investigate transgressions by President Bush and Vice President Cheney.
Conservative Republicans do not have a monopoly on anger.
Progressives have a legitimate right to be angry with Presidents Bush and Obama - and with Democrats who refuse to pursue a real progressive agenda in the interest of achieving a futile bipartisan coalition.
A "moderate" vision is not the answer to our nation's ills. Progressives should not concede the fight to change this country - even if too many Democrats join Republicans in deciding that a progressive agenda is off the table.
Sunday, July 18, 2010
Thank You, Governor Paterson
The Stop and Frisk Bill, which Governor David Paterson signed into law on July 16, 2010, does not curb the abusive practice in which more than half a million innocent New Yorkers, predominantly African Americans and Latinos, are stopped, questioned and frisked each year -- but not charged with a crime or even a violation.
But the bill is an important first step. This bill, which significantly applies only to stops in New York City, prohibits the NYPD from retaining personal information on people who are stopped-and-frisked but not criminally charged. This is a victory for the privacy rights of innocent people.
The symbolism of the bill signing ceremony cannot go unmentioned: Thanks to the hard work of the bill's sponsors, State Sen. Eric Adams and Assemblyman Hakeem Jeffries, elected officials from New York City stood with the governor to champion a bill which was bitterly opposed by both the mayor and police commissioner. In so doing, the state legislature performed an important check on Mayor Bloomberg's administration -- something which the New York City Council, under the leadership of Speaker Christine Quinn, has largely refused to do.
In exercising this limited control over the NYPD, the legislature's New York City delegation sends a subtle message to those police officers who live outside NYC but sometimes act as if they own our streets and neighborhoods, reminiscent of Rudy Giuliani's infamous Street Crimes Unit: This is our city. You work for us.
Maybe it is time for the NYPD to revisit the concept of community policing, in which police officers work with community leaders and residents -- a policing technique which Raymond Kelly favored until Rudy Giuliani declined to reappoint him to be his police commissioner after David Dinkins stepped down.
It is ironic indeed that Raymond Kelly has chose to embrace the police practices -- "broken windows" and "quality of life" -- of the very mayor who declined to retain him.
Scott
But the bill is an important first step. This bill, which significantly applies only to stops in New York City, prohibits the NYPD from retaining personal information on people who are stopped-and-frisked but not criminally charged. This is a victory for the privacy rights of innocent people.
The symbolism of the bill signing ceremony cannot go unmentioned: Thanks to the hard work of the bill's sponsors, State Sen. Eric Adams and Assemblyman Hakeem Jeffries, elected officials from New York City stood with the governor to champion a bill which was bitterly opposed by both the mayor and police commissioner. In so doing, the state legislature performed an important check on Mayor Bloomberg's administration -- something which the New York City Council, under the leadership of Speaker Christine Quinn, has largely refused to do.
In exercising this limited control over the NYPD, the legislature's New York City delegation sends a subtle message to those police officers who live outside NYC but sometimes act as if they own our streets and neighborhoods, reminiscent of Rudy Giuliani's infamous Street Crimes Unit: This is our city. You work for us.
Maybe it is time for the NYPD to revisit the concept of community policing, in which police officers work with community leaders and residents -- a policing technique which Raymond Kelly favored until Rudy Giuliani declined to reappoint him to be his police commissioner after David Dinkins stepped down.
It is ironic indeed that Raymond Kelly has chose to embrace the police practices -- "broken windows" and "quality of life" -- of the very mayor who declined to retain him.
Scott
Labels:
Eric Adams,
Hakeem Jeffries,
NYCLU,
NYPD,
Raymond Kelly
Saturday, July 17, 2010
40 Years Later
Leonard Levitt's take on the ongoing corruption scandal at the NYPD, involving a deliberate downgrading of felonies to misdemeanors, clearing of streets through false arrests and preventative detention, intimidation of crime victims, and the forced hospitalization in a psych ward of police whistle-blower Adrian Schoolcraft, is, in a word, stunning.
The famed police reporter compares the latest scandal to one of forty years ago, when no one initially believed Frank Serpico but eventually a full-blown corruption scandal emerged.
Leavitt notes that police union presidents publicly complained about the practice of downgrading crimes in 2005. But when the chairman of the mayor's corruption commission sought records to investigate the allegations, Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly refused to provide them, Mayor Michael Bloomberg remained silent... and the commission chairman resigned.
End of story?
Please read Leonard Levitt's column: http://nypdconfidential.com/columns/2010/100712.html
And please urge our public officials to demand the appointment of an independent commission, with subpoena power and public hearings, to investigate the latest corruption allegations against the NYPD.
The NYPD couldn't be trusted to investigate itself 40 years ago. And it can't be trusted with this responsibility now.
Scott
The famed police reporter compares the latest scandal to one of forty years ago, when no one initially believed Frank Serpico but eventually a full-blown corruption scandal emerged.
Leavitt notes that police union presidents publicly complained about the practice of downgrading crimes in 2005. But when the chairman of the mayor's corruption commission sought records to investigate the allegations, Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly refused to provide them, Mayor Michael Bloomberg remained silent... and the commission chairman resigned.
End of story?
Please read Leonard Levitt's column: http://nypdconfidential.com/columns/2010/100712.html
And please urge our public officials to demand the appointment of an independent commission, with subpoena power and public hearings, to investigate the latest corruption allegations against the NYPD.
The NYPD couldn't be trusted to investigate itself 40 years ago. And it can't be trusted with this responsibility now.
Scott
Tuesday, July 6, 2010
Now, It's Up to the Governor
New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg and Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly refuse to relinquish "broken windows"/"quality of life" police enforcement, a legacy of Mayor Rudy Giuliani and the Manhattan Institute (the conservative think tank whose ideas he promoted)
Thanks in large part to the leadership of State Sen. Eric Adams of Brooklyn, the State Legislature has passed a bill to curb one abusive component of broken windows policing -- permanent data retention on people who are stopped and frisked, but not arrested or fined.
In a free society, surely innocent people have the right to keep personal information out of a permanent police data base.
Now, it's up to Gov. David Paterson (who in the past has been sensitive to civil liberties issues), to do the right thing and sign this bill into law, notwithstanding the complaints of Mayor Bloomberg and Commissioner Kelly.
As columnist Bob Herbert argues in Monday's New York Times, signing this bill "should be an easy call for the governor."http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/06/opinion/06herbert.html
Civil liberties must matter in the world's greatest city.
Thanks in large part to the leadership of State Sen. Eric Adams of Brooklyn, the State Legislature has passed a bill to curb one abusive component of broken windows policing -- permanent data retention on people who are stopped and frisked, but not arrested or fined.
In a free society, surely innocent people have the right to keep personal information out of a permanent police data base.
Now, it's up to Gov. David Paterson (who in the past has been sensitive to civil liberties issues), to do the right thing and sign this bill into law, notwithstanding the complaints of Mayor Bloomberg and Commissioner Kelly.
As columnist Bob Herbert argues in Monday's New York Times, signing this bill "should be an easy call for the governor."http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/06/opinion/06herbert.html
Civil liberties must matter in the world's greatest city.
Labels:
civil liberties,
Eric Adams,
Michael Bloomberg,
NYCLU,
NYPD,
Raymond Kelly,
Stop-and-Frisk
Saturday, June 19, 2010
The NYPD Tapes
Is there no protection for whistle blowers in the NYPD?
In The Village Voice's "NYPD Tapes" series, secret audio recordings by a police officer in Brooklyn's 81st precinct in Bedford-Stuyvesant reveal a disturbing pattern of illegal police conduct:
* Manipulation of crime statistics to artificially lower numbers and categories of crimes;
* Threats against police officers if they don't meet their stop-and-frisk and arrest quotas;
* Intimidation of crime victims through "callbacks" to pressure them to downgrade or drop their complaints;
* Instructions to police officers to clear streets by arresting and detaining people for doing nothing more than standing around on streets in their own neighborhoods;
* Arrests of people for not showing identification outside of their own homes (this sounds like the NYPD version of arrests under Arizona's new immigration law, which even Mayor Bloomberg has denounced);
* Arrests by officers who didn't personally witness criminal activity (notwithstanding their own sworn complaints).
In the fourth installment of "The NYPD Tapes," the whistle blowing cop claims that a deputy chief stepped on his face with a boot, and subsequently dragged him to a psychiatric ward of a Queens hospital, where he was hospitalized and medicated against his will for six days.
The NYPD has had little to say about the accusations by the whistle blowing cop beyond stating that no one at the 81st precinct has been disciplined and claiming that there is an internal inquiry. Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly has declined to address a letter of complaint from City Council member Albert Vann and other elected officials, community leaders and clergy.
Unfortunately, there is no indication that investigations are underway by the Civil Rights Division of the Justice Department, the U.S. Attorneys of the Eastern or
Southern District of New York, or the Brooklyn District Attorney.
The police misconduct in Bed-Stuy is part of a broader pattern of police misconduct in New York City under Commissioner Kelly, which includes illegal arrests during the Republican National Convention in 2004; investigations and political arrests in Staten Island of individuals who did little more than "annoy" local politicians; bogus prostitution arrests of gay men; and hundreds of thousands of marijuana possession arrests each year, predominantly of African Americans and Latinos.
Civil liberties must matter in NYC. There must be accountability for systemic violations of our rights. We should never accept the attitude reflected by the police commissioner's recent statement that million dollar settlements of police misconduct lawsuits are simply the "cost of doing business" (New York Magazine, "Boss Kelly," May 24, 2010).
Surely we can fight crime without making criminals of NYPD officers. And surely things have changed in NYC, and the NYPD, since the days of famed whistle blower Frank Serpico, who coincidentally also worked for several years in the 81st precinct.
Scott
http://www.villagevoice.com/2010-06-15/news/adrian-school-craft-nypd-tapes-whistleblower/
http://www.villagevoice.com/2010-06-08/news/nypd-tapes-3-detective-comes-forward-downgrading-rape/
http://www.villagevoice.com/2010-05-11/news/nypd-tapes-part-2-bed-stuy
http://www.villagevoice.com/2010-05-04/news/the-nypd-tapes-inside-bed-stuy-s-81st-precinct/
In The Village Voice's "NYPD Tapes" series, secret audio recordings by a police officer in Brooklyn's 81st precinct in Bedford-Stuyvesant reveal a disturbing pattern of illegal police conduct:
* Manipulation of crime statistics to artificially lower numbers and categories of crimes;
* Threats against police officers if they don't meet their stop-and-frisk and arrest quotas;
* Intimidation of crime victims through "callbacks" to pressure them to downgrade or drop their complaints;
* Instructions to police officers to clear streets by arresting and detaining people for doing nothing more than standing around on streets in their own neighborhoods;
* Arrests of people for not showing identification outside of their own homes (this sounds like the NYPD version of arrests under Arizona's new immigration law, which even Mayor Bloomberg has denounced);
* Arrests by officers who didn't personally witness criminal activity (notwithstanding their own sworn complaints).
In the fourth installment of "The NYPD Tapes," the whistle blowing cop claims that a deputy chief stepped on his face with a boot, and subsequently dragged him to a psychiatric ward of a Queens hospital, where he was hospitalized and medicated against his will for six days.
The NYPD has had little to say about the accusations by the whistle blowing cop beyond stating that no one at the 81st precinct has been disciplined and claiming that there is an internal inquiry. Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly has declined to address a letter of complaint from City Council member Albert Vann and other elected officials, community leaders and clergy.
Unfortunately, there is no indication that investigations are underway by the Civil Rights Division of the Justice Department, the U.S. Attorneys of the Eastern or
Southern District of New York, or the Brooklyn District Attorney.
The police misconduct in Bed-Stuy is part of a broader pattern of police misconduct in New York City under Commissioner Kelly, which includes illegal arrests during the Republican National Convention in 2004; investigations and political arrests in Staten Island of individuals who did little more than "annoy" local politicians; bogus prostitution arrests of gay men; and hundreds of thousands of marijuana possession arrests each year, predominantly of African Americans and Latinos.
Civil liberties must matter in NYC. There must be accountability for systemic violations of our rights. We should never accept the attitude reflected by the police commissioner's recent statement that million dollar settlements of police misconduct lawsuits are simply the "cost of doing business" (New York Magazine, "Boss Kelly," May 24, 2010).
Surely we can fight crime without making criminals of NYPD officers. And surely things have changed in NYC, and the NYPD, since the days of famed whistle blower Frank Serpico, who coincidentally also worked for several years in the 81st precinct.
Scott
http://www.villagevoice.com/2010-06-15/news/adrian-school-craft-nypd-tapes-whistleblower/
http://www.villagevoice.com/2010-06-08/news/nypd-tapes-3-detective-comes-forward-downgrading-rape/
http://www.villagevoice.com/2010-05-11/news/nypd-tapes-part-2-bed-stuy
http://www.villagevoice.com/2010-05-04/news/the-nypd-tapes-inside-bed-stuy-s-81st-precinct/
Tuesday, June 15, 2010
Post-Sentencing Statement: From the Family of Fahad Hashmi
From the Family of Fahad Hashmi
http://www.muslimsforjustice.org/2010/06/post-sentencing-statement-from-the-family-of-fahad-hashmi/
June 10, 2010
A chapter has closed in our brother Fahad’s ordeal with the United States government. Yesterday’s sentence reflects a harsh imposition of 15 years in prison. The proceedings were a clear indication of the government’s gross exaggeration, distortion of facts, and fear-mongering to serve their purposes. Before he was sentenced, Fahad was allowed to speak, his first public statement since being arrested 4 years ago. In his speech, he expressed his gratitude to all his supporters, Muslim and non-Muslim, for their work on his behalf and commitment to seeking justice, took responsibility for his actions, and questioned the government’s treatment of him and Muslims more broadly.
Fahad’s case reveals the reign of tyranny that the government has imposed on its Muslim population. A vague and fickle material support statute has been used to criminalize Muslims–and particularly the political and religious associations of Muslims. The statute itself is over reaching and compromises the First Amendment freedoms of speech and association. It is the subject of criticism by human and civil rights organization and a recent Supreme Court case.
The severe solitary confinement imposed on Fahad is what many experts have defined as one of the worst forms of torture. Such pre-trial isolation is punitive and used to break the human psyche. The (SAMs) Special Administrative Measures Fahad was put under make torture sound like a harmless bureaucratic act. It is in fact an act of malice manifested. Fahad’s solitary confinement was applied under the presumption of innocence, yet this presumption is often discarded when it comes to Muslim defendants. The Muslim population is the victim of due process violations that lead them to the conclusion that there is an apparent and pronounced double standard within the Federal system.
This case–and the organizing around it– have been a watershed moment to shine a light on the larger treatment of the Muslim population. Agent provocateurs besiege our communities to entrap our population; illegal and pervasive surveillance have grown commonplace. The government sows fear about our community as something radical and violent while Muslims in this country are witnesses to some of the most horrendous acts against Muslims at home and abroad. Torture and prisoner abuse at Guantanamo, Abu Ghraib, and the MCC in NYC are only examples. The language is clever to define radicalism in very broad terms so any sign of Muslims increasing faith or criticizing the US government is inherently a sign of radicalism. The “see something say something” paradigm fosters this atmosphere of mistrust and hate.
There is clearly a clever and inflammatory campaign on Islam and Muslims and it is having a devastating effect on families and communities across the country. It is necessary for the government to change its stance, and policies regarding treatment of Muslims. As we have shown through this case many Muslims and non-Muslims will not be silenced about these rights abuses and will demand justice, fairness and humane treatment.
STATEMENT OF THE FAMILY OF SYED FAHAD HASHMI
http://www.muslimsforjustice.org/2010/06/post-sentencing-statement-from-the-family-of-fahad-hashmi/
June 10, 2010
A chapter has closed in our brother Fahad’s ordeal with the United States government. Yesterday’s sentence reflects a harsh imposition of 15 years in prison. The proceedings were a clear indication of the government’s gross exaggeration, distortion of facts, and fear-mongering to serve their purposes. Before he was sentenced, Fahad was allowed to speak, his first public statement since being arrested 4 years ago. In his speech, he expressed his gratitude to all his supporters, Muslim and non-Muslim, for their work on his behalf and commitment to seeking justice, took responsibility for his actions, and questioned the government’s treatment of him and Muslims more broadly.
Fahad’s case reveals the reign of tyranny that the government has imposed on its Muslim population. A vague and fickle material support statute has been used to criminalize Muslims–and particularly the political and religious associations of Muslims. The statute itself is over reaching and compromises the First Amendment freedoms of speech and association. It is the subject of criticism by human and civil rights organization and a recent Supreme Court case.
The severe solitary confinement imposed on Fahad is what many experts have defined as one of the worst forms of torture. Such pre-trial isolation is punitive and used to break the human psyche. The (SAMs) Special Administrative Measures Fahad was put under make torture sound like a harmless bureaucratic act. It is in fact an act of malice manifested. Fahad’s solitary confinement was applied under the presumption of innocence, yet this presumption is often discarded when it comes to Muslim defendants. The Muslim population is the victim of due process violations that lead them to the conclusion that there is an apparent and pronounced double standard within the Federal system.
This case–and the organizing around it– have been a watershed moment to shine a light on the larger treatment of the Muslim population. Agent provocateurs besiege our communities to entrap our population; illegal and pervasive surveillance have grown commonplace. The government sows fear about our community as something radical and violent while Muslims in this country are witnesses to some of the most horrendous acts against Muslims at home and abroad. Torture and prisoner abuse at Guantanamo, Abu Ghraib, and the MCC in NYC are only examples. The language is clever to define radicalism in very broad terms so any sign of Muslims increasing faith or criticizing the US government is inherently a sign of radicalism. The “see something say something” paradigm fosters this atmosphere of mistrust and hate.
There is clearly a clever and inflammatory campaign on Islam and Muslims and it is having a devastating effect on families and communities across the country. It is necessary for the government to change its stance, and policies regarding treatment of Muslims. As we have shown through this case many Muslims and non-Muslims will not be silenced about these rights abuses and will demand justice, fairness and humane treatment.
STATEMENT OF THE FAMILY OF SYED FAHAD HASHMI
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)